Beseiged by both Democrats and Republicans for months, U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales resigned today, having endured controversies over illegal wiretapping and accusations of politically-motivated firing of other US attorneys.
In the news, the most quoted sentence of Gonzales's incredibly brief statement was one that alluded to his immigrant upbringing and his being living proof of the American dream:
Even my worst days as Attorney General have been better than my father's best days.
I guess how you take that statement depends on how you feel about Gonzales. I think that under his term, the reputation of the Department of Justice has taken a hit and that the civil liberties of Americans have been compromised. As such, and as an immigrant myself, I feel that the mention of his "father's best days" is disingenuous.
First of all, in terms of the basic necessities of life,
of course Gonzales Jr. had it better than his father, what with the food, clothing, and shelter one can afford on a high-level government official's salary. To compare his own suffering to his father's undermines what his father might have gone through. Secondly, for Gonzales to invoke the so-called "American Dream" where anyone can succeed if they work hard enough insults those very ideals. Someone who "sought to
limit the legal rights of detainees at Guantanamo Bay" most certainly does not subscribe to the US tenets of "liberty and justice for all", nor does he care about the rights of American citizens, whose privacy he sought to invade by tapping their phones. Finally, it's as if the reminder about humble beginnings will somehow mitigate the criticism Gonzales has faced, the rhetoric equivalent of "you wouldn't hit a girl, would you?" To go back to point one, once you've had lunch with the President at his Crawford ranch, you can't really play the oppressed card anymore.
So while rising from a disadvantage background to become US Attorney General is indeed an accomplishment, speaking from a position of faux-humility is ridiculous. Once you've attained a certain level of power, it's no longer a question of how far you've come. It's what you do when you get there that counts.